Thursday, July 20, 2017

Non-circular Chainrings: Paradise or Placebo?

Introduction

Several of my riding companions have recently experimented with non-circular chainrings. As an anecdotal observation, most of them report a performance improvement and none have reverted to their original circular rings.  There have been several well-publicized results on non-circular chainrings in the last few years, most notably the Tour de France wins by both Bradley Wiggins and Chris Froome. Interestingly, however, Tim Kerrison, head coach at Team Sky, claims that credible research that has been undertaken is inconclusive. The question then arises: are these scientifically proven benefits or a placebo effect?  This article attempts to summarize current thinking with the disclaimer that I have not yet tried non-circular rings myself.

Concept

The idea is very simple: design and orient chainrings that allow the rider to spend less time in the least powerful parts of the pedal stroke, when the cranks are vertical, and more time in the most powerful parts of the pedal stroke, when the cranks are horizontal to the ground. That is, minimize the negative effect of the so-called “dead spot” which is the point at which the cranks are vertical and neither leg is generating any significant power. 

The single parameter that captures this idea is known as “crank angular velocity” which remains relatively constant throughout the pedal cycle with circular chainrings.  A non-circular chainring varies the crank angular velocity within the pedal cycle which, in turn, alters the time spent in each segment of the pedal cycle. To translate this into practical terms, the chainring should have a larger radius at the stronger segment of the pedal stroke and a lower radius at the weaker segment.

Bicycle engineers have been aware of the dead spot for over a century; non-circular chainrings were first tried back in the 1890s. The most notorious experiment in recent years was with Shimano’s Biopace rings (1983 to 1993). Recent studies claim that the downfall of Biopace was caused not by the shape of the rings but by their orientation.

There are several parameters that are relevant in non-circular ring design: the number of teeth, the “eccentricity” of the rings (the ratio of the major axis to the minor axis) and their orientation relative to the crank arms (including adjustability that allows rings to be “dialed-in” to the specific rider and bicycle set-up).  The various manufacturers of non-circular rings, for example Rotor, OSymetric, Bionicon and Absolute Black, all put their own particular spin (is there a joke there?) on the different variables.

  
Research

There have been a myriad of papers written on the subject, not all of them independent and unbiased.  Researchers have examined the physiological and performance differences between non-circular and round cranks on numerous occasions. Though there are some that report improvements of up to 6% with non-circular chainrings, a majority have concluded that, for efforts longer than one kilometer, there’s not much difference between round and non-circular chainrings. None reported a decreased performance. Additionally, not all authors are even agreed on the appropriate output parameters to be measured:  speed, power output, lactate threshold, heart-rate etc. 

In support of the use of non-circular rings for high-intensity events, an IJSSE study based their conclusions on a 1 km time trial study over a six-week period, using eight competitive male cyclists and triathletes using Rotor Q-Rings. Performance measures during the time trial were based on time to completion, speed and power output. In addition, physiological measures (oxygen consumption, heart rate, blood lactate were also monitored over the time span of the study.  The authors concluded that the Rotor Q-Rings provided a positive effect in the time trial and speculated that they could also prove beneficial in criterium-style racing events or at the end of a road race in which bicycle racers typically pedal at similar intensities and durations as the 1 km test. (“Effects of Chainring Type (Circular vs. Rotor Q-Ring) on 1 km Time Trial Performance”. Christiane R. O’Hara et al. International Journal of Sports Science and Engineering. September, 2011).

However, more recently, The Journal of Sports Science and Medicine published an article which documented extensive testing for blood lactate, power output and oxygen consumption but concluded that non-circular chainrings did not produce statistically significant differences over round ones. (“Physiological Responses during Cycling with Non-circular Chainrings and Circular Chainrings”. Alfredo Cordova et al. Journal of Sports Science & Medicine. May, 2014)

Studies at the University of Utah, while not challenging the fundamental premise behind the use of non-circular chainrings, addressed the issue from the perspective of joint-specific kinematics. The author concluded that use of non-circular chainrings did not either enhance or compromise joint-specific (collectively, the hip, knee and ankle) performance in trained cyclists. (“The Influence of Non-circular Chainrings on Maximal and Submaximal Cycling Performance”. Chee Hoi Leong. Department of Exercise and Sport Science, The University of Utah. December 2014).

Conclusions

The anecdotal evidence in support of non-circular chainrings, though not compelling, is certainly intriguing. Perhaps they are at the same stage of development and general acceptance as clipless pedals, integrated shifters and mountain bike suspension were in their early days …. innovations that are now regarded as de rigueur.

Nevertheless, it would appear that objective scientific experimentation in support of the use of non-circular chainrings is somewhat lacking and there is unquestionably no measure of consensus among the various researchers.  At the end of the day perhaps we need to just accept that even a placebo has the potential to offer a significant performance gain.

Some challenges

If you decide to give non-circular chainrings a try, be aware that:

·       Not all of the various manufacturers’ non-circular rings fit all cranks. Be sure you understand your crankset’s spider pattern, bolt circle diameter etc.
·       All front derailleurs are optimized to work with round chainrings and some degradation of mechanical performance might result with non-circular rings. In this regard, front derailleur fine-tuning might a tad more finicky.
·       The risk of dropping a chain appears higher with non-circular rings so consider installing a chain catcher on the front derailleur.
·       Because non-circular chainrings change the angular velocity of the crankarms and thus the power transmitted to any power-meter strain gauges that yu might use, any historical power data from your prior use of circular rings cannot be compared to the data set from the new rings. 


18 comments:

  1. Helpful content for us. Have you need of cheap flights to florida, cheap flights to new york, cheap flights, cheap tickets, flights to vegas, flights to miami Cheaper airfare to long distance travel by flights. Book a flights to anywhere with the help of online price comparison

    ReplyDelete
  2. Cloud Services IT Support offers a comprehensive range of IT services that enables businesses to gain maximum benefit from their IT infrastructure by leveraging the services provided. If you are curious to know more about terraform Iac, check here.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Maplestory m mod is one of the famous game. In this game we need to play it with the help of maplestory m mod but it is a risky job to get maplestory m mod from outside, because when we download maplestory m mod from outside we may get virus in your phone, so we need to use our phone for downloading maplestory m mod only from our site.

    ReplyDelete
  4. GBwhatsapp apk is an amazing android app which you can use to chat with your friends & family members for free. It is a great alternative to whatsapp . You are now able to send unlimited group messages and images. You will feel like a good experience after using this app.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Lovestruck Mod Apk is a dating simulator where you play as the main character, who just moved to a new town. You can date a variety of different people at your school. Each date will have multiple endings. The goal is to make all the characters fall in love with you. For more Info visit us at https://fasterapk.com/lovestruck-mod-apkk/

    ReplyDelete
  6. Cars fast as lightning mod apk is one of the most famous games anyone can play. There are so many people playing this game and having fun with it. Just like all other games, this game has its own rules and regulations. A player has to follow the instructions of the game in order to play it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. GTA Vice City Mod Apk OBB is a game for Android devices that lets you play the popular game on your phone or tablet. The game is set in Vice City, which is a fictional city based on Miami. You can play as one of several characters, and complete missions to progress through the game. There are also plenty of side missions and other activities to keep you busy.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Bike Mayhem Mod Latest Version is a new mod for Android that turns your phone into a deadly bike track. The app comes with 10 different levels, and each one has multiple obstacles to avoid and other riders to bump into. If you complete the level in first place, you get a bonus. The game is free to download, you can easily upgrade your vehicle, rider, and track.

    ReplyDelete
  9. GB WhatsApp Lite is a simplified version of the popular WhatsApp messaging app. The app is available for free on Google Play and App Store, and it offers a reduced interface that's optimised for low-end devices. GB WhatsApp Lite offers all the features of the full version of the app, including group chats, voice and video calls, and message forwarding. For more Info visit us at https://getmodz.com/gb-whatsapp-lite/

    ReplyDelete
  10. In this article, you will learn about a new app called Pato Player. This app is a great way to watch your favorite soccer teams play without having to go to the stadium. With Pato Player, you can watch live games and highlights from anywhere in the world. The app is available for Android and iOS devices. For more Info visit us at https://apkspike.com/pato-player-apk/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hungry Shark Mod Apk 2022 is one of the most popular games on Android, and with good reason. The game is simple to play but challenging, and it's really fun to see how long you can survive. Hungry Shark Mod APK takes all of that fun and ramps it up to 11. with new sharks, new levels, and new challenges, this modded apk is sure to keep you entertained for hours on end.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Mini Militia Mod App Download is a popular Android game that has been downloaded over 50 million times. The game is a two-dimensional shooter game with an online multiplayer mode. Mini Militia Mod APK allows players to access unlimited ammunition and flying power.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Slither io Mod Apk is a new and exciting io game that has just hit the market. The game is full of action and excitement, and it is sure to keep you entertained for hours on end. The game is easy to play, and it is sure to provide you with hours of fun. If you are looking for an io game that is packed with action, then Slither io is definitely worth checking out. For more Info visit us at https://peerapk.com/slither-io-mod-apk/

    ReplyDelete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Mobile bus simulator hack unlimited money are becoming increasingly popular. This is because they offer an interesting and realistic experience that can be enjoyed on the go. There are a number of different mods available, all of which offer a unique way to experience the game. Whether you want to experience the game as if you were driving a real bus or want to take control of the passengers, there is a mod for you.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Mod Apk is a modding tool for Android that allows users to customize games and applications. It is available free of charge from the Google Play Store. Mod Apk was created by developers who wanted to make it easier for users to modify their apps. This makes it possible to change the game's graphics, sound, and other features. For more Info visit this apk festival.

    ReplyDelete
  17. The Mini Militia Old Version is an android app that allows players to create and manage their own private militias. The app includes features such as creating and managing teams, recruiting members, and issuing commands. Players can also customize their militia's appearance and weapons. For more Info visit us at https://nyapk.com/mini-militia-old-version/

    ReplyDelete